On the allegedly Higgs boson claimed to be discovered by ATLAS and CMS Collaborations on July 4th 2012
THE CASE OF THE THETA^+(1540) PENTAQUARK
In 2003 the LEPS and CLAS collaborations reported the evidence of an exotic pentaquark known as Theta^+(1540) [1,2]. The event caused a lot of excitement among the community of high energy particle physicists. Surprisingly, the data analysis carried out by some other collaborations didn't corroborate the finding. This gave place to a great debate about the possible existence of this resonance. Thereafter hundreds of papers have been published on this topic. By 2005 there existed in the literature at least 33 data analyses from around 20 collaborations all over the world. From these 33 reports, 17 claimed the pentaquark observation whereas the rest show no evidence. The common factor among the positive results is the low statistics whilst, with relatively high statistics, the resonance turns out to be imperceptible. With the aim of settling down this issue, in 2006, the same CLAS collaboration repeated the experiment with a great number of data... This time however, the result was negative (see Fig. 1).